Eye for an Eye is a 2025 American supernatural horror film directed by Colin Tilley and written by Elisa Victoria and Michael Tully. Based on Victoria’s graphic novel Mr. Sandman, the movie stars Whitney Peak, S. Epatha Merkerson, Finn Bennett, Laken Giles, Golda Rosheuvel, and Carson Minniear.
Set in a quiet Florida town, the film follows Anna, a teen grieving her parents’ sudden death. She moves in with her blind grandmother and befriends two local teens—but an act of cruelty ties them all to a deadly legend.
As a vengeful spirit begins haunting their dreams, Anna must find a way to stop the curse before it claims their lives.
The film explores tough themes like bullying, guilt, and revenge through a surreal and scary lens. Eye for an Eye had its limited U.S. theatrical and digital release on June 20, 2025.
Eye for an Eye Age Rating
Eye for an Eye is unrated, but based on its content, it is most suitable for viewers aged 17 and above. If officially rated, it would likely receive an R rating due to its disturbing violence, intense psychological horror, and mature themes.
This film is not recommended for teenagers under 17, as the content may be too graphic and emotionally unsettling.
Here is a spoiler-free breakdown of what parents should know:
Violence & Peril
The movie includes intense violence, especially in dream sequences. Mr. Sandman’s attacks are creepy and gory, involving mutilation of the eyes. While not constant, these scenes are graphic and can be upsetting. There’s also a scene where a violent act by teens triggers the curse, though the worst of it is suggested rather than shown.
Language
Some strong language is used throughout, including curse words and insults during emotional or stressful moments.
Mature Themes
This film deals with grief, trauma, bullying, and guilt. There’s a strong emotional weight behind the horror. Themes of complicity, remorse, and violence among teens are deeply explored. The film’s tone is dark and emotionally heavy.
Is Eye for an Eye Suitable for Teens?
Ages 10–12: Not suitable: The violence and psychological horror are far too intense for pre-teens. The story also deals with dark emotional themes that may be confusing or frightening.
Ages 13–17: Not recommended for most: While some older teens who enjoy horror might be curious, the gory content and disturbing themes make this film better suited for mature viewers. Parents should use caution.
This film is best suited for adults due to its graphic horror, dream-based violence, and intense emotional themes.
What Parents Should Know
Watch First If Unsure: Preview the movie to judge if it’s appropriate for your teen’s sensitivity level.
Discuss Bullying and Guilt: If older teens watch it, talk about the film’s moral message and the impact of peer pressure and inaction.
Be Prepared for Scares: The film’s villain and dream imagery can be frightening and visually disturbing.
Official Trailer
FAQs
Q: Is Eye for an Eye appropriate for teens?
A: Not for most. It contains disturbing content and violent scenes that may be too intense for younger viewers.
Q: Is the violence graphic?
A: Yes. The film includes scenes involving eye-related gore and supernatural horror.
Q: Where can I watch Eye for an Eye?
A: The film was released in select U.S. theaters and on digital platforms on June 20, 2025.